San Francisco Water, Sewage Rates to Skyrocket in July

Written by Hope Johnson. Posted in News

Published on April 07, 2009 with 5 Comments

_w2w4945_std.jpg
San Francisco residents can expect to pay a lot more
for their water and sewage service beginning in July
if a majority of property owners fail to object to new rate hikes
proposed by the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission.
Photo by Luke Thomas

By Hope Johnson

April 7, 2009

San Francisco water and sewer rates are set to increase substantially in July unless a majority of property owners object to rate increases currently being proposed by the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission.

But, there’s a catch. Due to the passage of Prop 218, objections to the proposed rate increases must be received in writing.

The intent of Prop 218, passed by California voters 1996, is to prevent local governments from arbitrarily increasing taxes and fees under Prop 13, the constitutional amendment limiting property taxes to 1 percent of cash value. But the proposition also mandates that opposition to municipal rate increases must be expressed in writing by property owners.

According to legally required literature mailed by the SFPUC to all potentially affected residents, the proposed rate increases cannot be implemented if written “protests are received by a majority of the affected property owners and customers” by May 5.

Deputy City Attorney John Roddy, attending yesterday’s Rate Fairness Board hearing on the SFPUC’s proposed rate increases, acknowledged that for complaints to be officially accepted, they must be sent to the SFPUC in writing by the customer directly responsible for paying the utility bill, generally the property owner.

Renter objections may not be considered official even when submitted in writing, Roddy said. Despite comprising nearly 63 percent of city residents, renters generally do not fall within the legal definition of “customer” because charges are either incorporated into rent or paid directly to landlords rather than the utility.

“It’s a gray area in Prop 218,” Roddy conceded when asked if the SFPUC would officially accept written objections from renters. “The SFPUC needs to be able to verify the comment is from an affected customer.”

Roddy expressed doubt the SFPUC would address the issue for the current rate increase proposal because written complaints would have to be received by tens of thousands of renters to meet the majority requirement.

Roddy also said he was uncertain if emailed objections would be accepted as official objections to the proposed rate increases.

Proposed increases will double residential water bills by 2014, consecutively raising rates in sizable increments by 13.4, 14.4, 12.5, 12.9, and 7.1 percent respectively over the next five years. Residential sewer rates will also double within five years under the SFPUC’s proposed rate changes.

According to SFPUC Assistant General Manager and Chief Financial Officer Todd Rydstrom, the average residential bill, currently $42.03 per month, would swell to $73.68 per month by 2014.

“As I’m sure you all know, rates for the water and sewer service in the city and county will be rising again,” said Rate Fairness Board Vice Chair Howard Ash. “I expect they will continue to rise for years to come.”

“It is coming at a very bad time for the average Joe out there,” a property owner responded during public comment. “I would ask that these costs… be spread out over a longer period of time and matched somehow to inflation. Inflation is very low now, less than 1 percent.”

According to SFPUC Director of Communications Tony Winnicker, the proposed rate increases will fund a $4.4 million Water System Improvement Plan (WISP), approved by voters in 2002. The plan provides for upgrades to outdated water and sewage systems, improved flood controls, and preparation for future droughts, climate change and earthquakes.

The changes fail to allocate a share of the sewer rate increases to commercial customers, leaving their sewer rates unchanged over the next five years.

At no time during the hearing did any commissioner or SFPUC staff member explain the official procedure for submitting protests, or discuss the May 5th deadline for written objections.

Tenants and property owners may have one final, more traditional avenue for opposing the rate increases. The Board of Supervisors has authority to reject the approved rates within 30 days prior to the date the new rates are scheduled to take effect, currently July 1, 2009.

Elected officials are taking notice of the impact the large increases will have on rate payers. District 4 Supervisor Carmen Chu said today she will continue to monitor the progress of WISP projects the SFPUC has stated increased fees will fund.

The Rate Fairness Board plans to make its recommendation to the SFPUC on the proposed increases during an April 28th hearing to be held at 1:30 p.m. in Room 400 of City Hall. Approval of rates by the SFPUC is scheduled for May 5th at 10:00 a.m. in Room 416.

Sanctioned objections to the rate increases are those submitted in writing by the May 5 deadline to the SFPUC Commission Secretary at 1155 Market Street, 11th Floor, San Francisco, CA 94103, and must include the property parcel number or SFPUC customer account number.

5 Comments

Comments for San Francisco Water, Sewage Rates to Skyrocket in July are now closed.

  1. It’s absurd to make residents (both homeowners and renters) bear the entire cost of this upgrade while exempting commercial accounts. I think San Franciscans of all political persuasions can agree on that.

    I’m not sure how effective it’ll be, but I’ve started a Facebook cause to see what we can do to stop it:
    http://tinyurl.com/dl4fow

    For now, contact your district supervisor and complain loudly.

  2. San Francisco has an aging infrastructure, and the Water rate increases are reflective of (1) a local public entity’s inefficiency and (2) not enough customers to spread the costs to. Let this be a warning to those who think SF should be in the electric and gas utility business. If you think these water rate hikes are severe, expect much higher increases if the Board tries to buy out PG&E.

  3. Hi Karen

    “How much of this increase can landlords pass through to tenants?”

    My knowledge on the topic is limited but it’s my understanding landlords are allowed to pass through 50% of increases due to WISP projects. I don’t how this is determined but I believe SFPUC water bills indicate which charges are eligible for a pass through (http://www.sfgov.org/site/rentboard_page.asp?id=55887).

    “Also, anyone know how long the increased rates that are due to the WISP project will last?”

    No mention has been made of the increases being temporary. Not unlike local bridge toll increases, I can’t imagine the SFPUC would ever voluntarily reduce rates!

  4. Landlords are able to do water passthroughs to the tenant (at 50%, I believe) … and it’s a relatively simple process through the Rent Board. I could be wrong, but tenants are *NOT* able to file Financial Hardship Appeals — like they can for capital improvements, operation & maintenance or utility passthroughs.

    On the bright side, I’ve had clients with water passthroughs … and the rent increase (compared with other ones mentioned above) is usually pretty small.

  5. I feel like I should already know the answer to this question but I don’t. How much of this increase can landlords pass through to tenants? Is it 50% (even if your current lease says the landlord pays water and sewer)?

    Also, anyone know how long the increased rates that are due to the WISP project will last? And am I correct in assuming only these WISP project-related rate increases can be passed through?